Elite Tier

San Antonio Brahmas: 9.5/10

Kellen Mond’s presence makes the quarterback situation for the Brahmas the most dynamic in the league. His combination of NFL experience, arm talent, and mobility alone provides the blueprint that other quarterbacks should try to follow in spring football. The only thing keeping this from a perfect 10 is the lack of proven depth behind him.

Arlington Renegades: 8.8/10

Luis Perez has perfected spring football quarterback play. His consistency and leadership, mixed with Lindsey Scott Jr.’s development, gives Arlington one of the most reliable QB rooms in the league. Lacking the elite ceiling of Mond, they make up for with proven production.

St. Louis BattleHawks (With McCarron): 9.3/10

With McCarron, the BattleHawks have a championship-level quarterback with singular experience in spring football. His leadership and history of clutch performances are invaluable.

Solid Tier

St. Louis BattleHawks (Sans McCarron): 4.2/10

That ranking sans McCarron cannot be stressed enough. The backup situation has not been developed due to McCarron’s strong presence, leaving them awfully vulnerable if he doesn’t return.

Michigan Panthers: 7.8/10

Stability for certain, the Perkins/Perry tandem is very solid. Both have proven they can win games, but neither has shown elite potential. It’s not the highest ceiling, but depth and reliability boost this ranking to very strong.

Birmingham Stallions: 7.5/10

Corral has grown into the role nicely. He isn’t quite at the elite tier some had him pegged for when he was in college, but he is a solid starter with room for growth. The grade reflects his current play with upside included.

Concerning Tier

DC Defenders: 5.5/10

The post-Ta’amu regression has been real. Slovis does flash at times, but he just hasn’t been consistent enough. There’s potential for them to get better, but current play caps their grade.

Memphis Showboats: 4.8/10
Cookus and Dormady provide experienced depth but without starting-caliber impact. Their grade reflects adequate backup-level play but falls way short of what is needed from a primary starter.

Houston Roughnecks: 3.5/10

Most glaring quarterback need in the league. Rating takes into account both current roster situation and struggle to take care of the position well. This, for the lack of at least a clear starter-level player, keeps the rating at or near the bottom.

Methodology Used

Ratings are based on:
Starter quality: 50%
Depth: 20%
Experience level: 15%
Potential for growth: 15%

These weighted factors consider both immediate impact and long-term stability. How drastic of a swing St. Louis took with its rating based on McCarron’s status shows how one player can completely alter a team’s outlook during spring football.

Ratings subject to change as rosters change approaching the 2025 season.

Who Are The Most Passionate Fans in the UFL?